What makes a movie “smart”?

Recently this summer Inception was heaped with constant acclaim about it being a “smart” blockbuster and fans saying it was a “thinking man’s” movie. I’m curious about what this exactly means though. Inception isn’t a particularly “smart” movie in the since that it leaves any questions that are particularly interesting or any questions at all. Like most Christopher Nolan movies, the audience is beaten to death in the head with exposition upon exposition. Now I’m well aware that fans of the movie can assuage this fault by saying it’s necessary or what have you. However, I’m not making an argument about whether it was or wasn’t necessary or about Inception exclusively. The issue of course is what makes a movie smart. The only question that you’re left with in the movie is in the cliffhanger ending. I’m not anti-cliffhanger ending, but I wouldn’t say a movie is smart because it has it. The manner comes down to which party in the discussion is better at rhetoric or can point out the most convincing information presented in the movie to decide what was what. That’s not particularly interesting to me.

So the conversation must go back to what makes a movie smart. I would say the same reason I deem a person smart. It’s not being able to recite whatever great thinkers that have existed all throughout time at the drop of the time. Nor is it the ability to do something consistent or competently. I believe a smart movie is one that either presents an idea in a through and unique fashion or one that just breathes open and honest intellectual curiosity. John Cassavettes is someone I say was a smart director because while his movies didn’t tackle grand philosophical or scientific (as most movies that are deemed smart are Sci-Fi movies) in his movies, there is a love for the percularities in human life throughout all of his movies. And because he was able to not to simply understand this but portray it in a way that the audience could feel and think is why everything hits in such a profound way. Or another favorite of mine is Waking Life, which could be accurately described as “Intro Into Philosophy: The Movie”. I do believe that misses the point of the movie. Because even though it can be very verbose or abstract, when it takes you on your journey ever story and conversation had doesn’t seem contrived in the slightest. Every character in the film feels open and honest about their beliefs, even if everything they say isn’t fully worked out to themselves. Wonderful movie of ideas, even if they’ve all been presented before.


About panamaenrique

Afro-Latino film lover in NYC. I love blues, jazz, soul, funk, and everything else under the sun. Any questions, comments, or concerns about anything I say, feel free to hit me up. My contact info is there and I'll be sure to give you a lengthy response about what I said and why I said it.
This entry was posted in Uncategorized. Bookmark the permalink.

2 Responses to What makes a movie “smart”?

  1. Justin says:

    You’re a decent writer but you should really proofread stuff before committing it to digital.

    • I try to update my blog often, but when I don’t write for a long period of time, I spam out a post like that. I just check to see if there are any typos and move on to post it. Thank you for commenting!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s